Portable Aircon for Upstairs or Split System?

Been thinking of getting some sort of portable aircon unit for upstairs.

It gets pretty hot during summer upstairs when it’s above 35. Insulation isn’t the issue really as it’s all well insulated in the roof space. I was thinking of getting split installed upstairs but considering it’s pretty open space, if I want split, it has to be in one of large bedroom. But then I don’t want to end up installing split in all 3 bedrooms upstairs. Getting even single split installed upstairs going to need some fair cable run to the meter. It’s going to cost a bit of fortune really.

So, may be getting portable aircon is a good idea? This way I can put it in main bedroom or in open area to cool upstairs down. Just want to see what’s others experience with portable aircon? Or should I bite the bullet and just go with split on wall in main bedroom? I don’t think installing split in each room will be good idea for my pocket. Looking for some helpful tips and ideas. How is your experience with portable unit, vent and noise. Especially if you live in bit larger double storey house.

Comments

  • +2

    Without a shadow of a doubt, if you don't want to do a proper solution and air condition all the rooms, still get a split system over portable. Possibly a double-head one, in the most central space and the main bedroom. (or better yet, the ceiling cassette kind as they are often better at distributing air centrally … but more expensive). Or just one in the open area or main bedroom if you can't afford that … and couple it with well placed fans.

    I have both splits and a portable in different areas of the house. I don't really use the portable. Despite being hot, just last week I didn't run a portable air con for more than 1 minute because what I didn't consider until I was rudely reminded by turning it on when trying to go to sleep, is they are often much louder, too loud to run in the same room as you sleep and despite the name, they are often quite large and not that portable, you have to set up a thing in the window to send out the hot air and seal off the window around it, which is a water leak / break-in risk, and ugly. It's not like you will wheel it in with you when you go to bed and back again to the other spaces like a portable fan. So, they often stay in one spot taking up space and looking like a turd, and so aren't really much more portable than a split system in the short term. Additionally, the occupants of each room will all be hot on a hot day / night at the same time - and it can't be in two places at once anyway. They are good for renters where the house rented doesn't have an A/C to keep in one spot, and take it with you when you move out, and that's about it.

    The other considerations are they are usually way less electrically efficient - which adds up to more cost in the long run and usually don't heat and A/Cs are an efficient heater in winter. On a power hungry appliance like A/Cs, always consider efficiency.

    Portable is basically a shorter life span, lower performance, temporary / ugly, louder solution IMHO - a disposable appliance.

    Whereas a good proper air conditioner properly installed is an asset of the house, and if selected correctly, can be an efficient way to heat and cool. They aren't usually all that expensive for a bedroom split system when considered as a long term investment of the house.

    Then, what I have had success with, is pre-conditioned air circulation. If you have a good size air conditioner in one central room (e.g. split), cool that room well, you then select which other rooms you want to cool, shut off the doors to the ones you don't, open the doors to the ones you do and have a window cracked (with window lock) in each to allow air flow out of them, then put a fan in the door way pushing preconditioned air into that room from the central cooled room. Works surprisingly well over time - not instantly such as in the room with the A/C itself, but if on for an hour before bed then you have the fan on for the night and rely on that, together with the fact the house is well insulated and the cool from the central room should radiate into the larger space, it is good enough to sleep with sharing the cool across multiple bedrooms when coupled with a fan on you for each room. … However your family have to be willing to sleep with bedroom doors open. Otherwise you need separate systems and there's no way around that.

  • +1

    I've never used a portable aircon that was worth it for me, usually they either didn't cool for me, or to get it to cool made it so loud it was impossible to sleep or hear the tv with it. Apparently it has something to do with it has to have an outlet to exchange the heat outside otherwise it can't actually cool the air properly (so maybe the ones with two outlets in and out are better?). I unno if thats right, but I'd rather have a single big AC and leave all the room doors open to cool down and a fan at night then a portable. but that me. At the very least, check how loud the portable is.

  • +4

    Portable aircon ONLY if you have no chopice to install split system or even a damn box aircon in a window.

    • +1

      true I forgot about that option, the box in the window A/Cs are still better than portables

  • +3

    Portable Aircons are beyond terrible, have a lot of experience of all the different options when I was renting. Even with proper installation (external venting) they hardly work, are loud, terribly power inefficient etc etc. Do it once and do it right, when I bought my own place and could install a split I was so happy, I would pay 4x the price for a split over a portable and still think I was getting a deal!!

  • +3

    Rather go ceiling fans over portable air conditioning if cost is an issue

    • +1

      As long as op has a decent breeze coming in through the windows, 100% ceiling fan especially if roof is already insulated.

  • +3

    Why do you think you have to run cable back to the DB? Both my "single room" splits at the rear of the house are wired into the GPO circuit. Ditto at the wife's house - 3 splits all wired into the GPO circuit(s). All quite legal.

    • This. Running a dedicated circuit for a small modern aircon is plain stupid. They draw 3A max.
      Yes, once upon a time, the lights would dim when the compressor started due to high startup current. That is ancient history.

    • Ok that’s pretty interesting. I did get couple of tradied and they both looked how far is the meter box etc. Based on the cable run etc. they came up with quote. Probably it’s because split size is going to be on larger end like 5kw or even bigger. But still a good point

  • +2

    The only time you should use a portable is when a split isn't possible. Especially when you own the home.

  • You'll get annoyed by the noise downstairs that comes through the floor. Plus these things don't work that well, even if you get the best unit, ditto the cheap ones at places like Bunnings.

  • Portable aircons are the worst things to exist. You need to be lying on top of the damn things to cool yourself. It is not even a valid comparison. I had one.. went to hard waste the next year.

  • Thanks everyone. I do have evaporative unit on the roof but I have found they don’t work very well when humid and temperatures above 35 really. Also i have closed its vents through the house to prevent backflow of cool and hot air for insulation purposes. Closing these vents did help us in winter with keeping place bit warmer. Not keen on using these evaps anymore tbh. I should have gone for better cooling solution when we built. Sounds like going for split or some double head thing is best solution forward.

    • What colour is your roof? I hope it's not one of those McMansion dark grey tile ones unless you're in Tassie or the Snowy Mountains.
      Do you have direct sun coming through your windows at any time after noon?
      Preventing heat entering the home in the first place can be a better solution to ejecting the heat with air con.

      • House was built in 1928 and has a Monier concrete dark tile roof. There are 3 solar driven air extractors installed in the roof to help reduce the cavity temperature.
        The house has roof insulation and is triple brick construction.
        Minimal North facing windows and the Wast facing windows have the blinds lowered after noon.

  • But then I don’t want to end up installing split in all 3 bedrooms upstairs. Getting even single split installed upstairs going to need some fair cable run to the meter. It’s going to cost a bit of fortune really.

    Just do it - it's a small price to pay for what should be decades of good service. For bedrooms, just go with the smallest 2.0kW splits, and a reputable brand (e.g. Mitsubishi, Fujitsu, Panasonic…etc.) and they will last you forever.

    I would personally always go with individual units as opposed to multi-head units - they are more reliable, and you'll be out of pocket less if an outdoor unit kicks the can. They are also more energy efficient particularly if you're not using all rooms as the heat pump becomes less efficient when operating outside of its target window.

    If you're already annoyed with the sub-par evaporative unit, don't make the same mistake twice to go with another sub-par solution - just bite the bullet once and enjoy the new system. If you're in VIC, split systems are also really good for heating in the winter - e.g. we save almost $1k per year on the gas bill by turning off the ducted gas heater and only running the bedroom split heater at night in winter.

Login or Join to leave a comment