My local had heaps of new release titles for $70 like Skyrim, Batman, BF3, MW3 etc = $46 each game when you buy 3, and they were all in excellent condition.
You can mix and match across platforms too.
I grabbed Enslaved, Michael Jackson The Experience (for the WAF I promise!) and Bioshock Steelbook for $36 : )
Heaps of $28 games - from memory RDR, NBA 2K11, Bioshock 2, MW2, NFS Hot Pursuit, Alan Wake, Operation Flashpoint: Dragon Rising etc.
Also, GAME have extended their 7 day returns policy until January 10th from today.
you would have to be mental to pay $70 full price for any game (that wasnt a collectors/limited edition with some sentimental value to you) second hand.