• expired

Quality in Ear Headphone- Comet by Campfire $239.20 (Normally $300) 20% off via eBay Addicted to Audio

180
PASSIONATE

Campfire Comets are quality in ear headphones that are considered entry level audiophile grade by many reviewers. I decided to take a leap of faith and bought a pair at $240.

The quality of sound and construction are top notch apparently after hours of reading reviews and comparing with headphones I have had personal experience with. The headphones come with tips that can provide good isolation from ambient noise. I was originally looking for wireless noise cancelling headphones but the price, performance, and problems reported with wireless products made me think the technology is still in the entry phase so I went back to wires.

My previous headphone was the Original Monster Turbines which I imported from Amazon US for $90 AUD (rrp $250 ish from memory) and lasted for a good 4 years from daily use before the wire loosened on one earbud (a known issue).

After the 20% eBay discount from a quality and trusted local store addicted to audio, there was nothing else in my knowledge at $240 for in ear headphones that offered solid sound, isolation, construction, and consistent performance (vs wireless).
.
.
.
If you want to know, here’s my 2019 journey navigating the complicated headphone space:
.
.
.
The last time I looked for a pair of headphones was in 2014.

This time, I was looking for some quality ear phones with relatively good isolation for commuting on the train or airplane where ambient traffic noise is relatively loud (80db). Wireless options were a plus since they weren’t widely available in 2014. I first looked for wireless solutions with active noise cancelling but quickly found them to be limiting where they are not truely wireless (the best I have found was QuietControl 30 wireless headphones but I wasn’t pleased with the audio quality at the price point, good but not great).

To my surprise looking into the wireless range, there is a dedicated category of headphones actually named ‘true wireless’. What a funny name to further qualify ‘wireless’ I thought. Here I found two headphones to be decent- MASTER & DYNAMIC MW07 and Sennheiser Momentum True In-Ear Wireless. However, these were above my pay grade and people have still reported issues of sync, dropouts, etc, something you’d expect to work flawlessly at $500 mark. Back to the scratch board.

Having considered the drawbacks of active noise cancelling requiring a typically larger footprint or expect a shorter battery life, I then looked into passive noise cancelling where the design of the headphone takes into consideration of ambient noise reduction. Smart. Whilst sound quality is highly subjective (e.g. the nura headphone demonstrates this), isolation was an easier and more objective attribute to evaluate from a group of reviewers (a good sample size of different ears). With an additional preference to avoid mainstream brands that sell into retail stores with some exceptions where brands were from an audiophile pedigree (e.g. sennheiser), this drove me into looking for IEMs (in ear monitors). I’ve had listened to other kinds of high quality headphones before (Denon, Bower & Wilkins, Kef, Sennheiser) but nothing in ear.

After reviewing various IEMs, entry level IEMs were the only ones I would pay for for my purposes so I narrowed down to a handful based on reviews on prestigious headphone sites. These websites and YouTube compared the mid and high range of the entry level IEMs I was looking into and gave me an idea of price/performance. Whilst all IEMs were excellent in sound quality with minor differences to the typical ear, the brand Campfire stood out due to their solid construction quality (metal chassis, detachable cables).

Original PASSIONATE 20% off All Items at Selected Sellers on eBay Deal Post

Related Stores

eBay Australia
eBay Australia
Marketplace
Addicted To Audio
Addicted To Audio

closed Comments

  • +1

    +1 for the story in description.

    Username checksout

    • Cheers mate. One way to spend a Sunday morning.

  • +2

    For true budget entry level earphones, try the KZ ZS3 or ZS5. They have great reviews and I've personally tried the ZS5. I've owned several earphones and 2 custom IEMs and can attest that the ZS5 punches far above its price range. They're also probably the cheapest earphones to have detachable cables. The only downside is that it looks cheap af.

    • -3
      • +1

        yeah those, they might be cheaper on aliexpress.

        • thanks

      • why is this getting negged?

        • People don't like direct links to products maybe?

    • +1

      The KZ ZSN's are probably a better starting point imo.

      • +1

        ooh, haven't seen those before. They look pretty good aesthetics wise.

      • cool looking headphones. Are these better than sound magic e10?

  • +1

    If you want to know, here’s my 2019 journey navigating the complicated headphone space:

    still a better love story than twilight….

    • +1

      no two words scare me more than 'twilight marathon'.

  • Is it compatible with iphone 8+?
    Is it bluetooth compatible?

    • +2

      These have MMCX connectors so you can add a bluetooth cable, but they aren't bluetooth compatible out of the box.

      • This. Sony MUC-M2BT1 are the best neck style cable and can be had for $150 odd if you're willing to figure out how to order from Taobao.

        Others there's Bluetooth DACs for around the $100 that are apparently audiophile quality - I can't remember what they're called but they're available on AliExpress

        • any non bluetooth wired in ear headphones you would recommend?

          • @Hardearnedcash: I'm using MMCX or 2-pin IEMs so you can use them wired or with a wireless addon (such as the Sony above). Currently I'm using a pair of BGVP DM6…I'm still undecided on them as they have a very flat response. Before these I was dabbling with KZs. ZSR was my favourite to date, the ZS10 was way too uncomfortable.

  • +1

    Why do these look so bad? :(

    • They look cheap and nasty!

      • They look pretty tacky to me…

    • They remind me of picnic chocolate bars.

  • How's the low end, sub bass?

    • According to Headphonics, I think they mean decent, it is good for its price.

      https://headfonics.com/2018/06/campfire-audio-comet-review/2…

      "Bass

      The Comets low-end quantity and lack of roll-off for a single BA are very impressive. Quite a lot of older designs will fall way and quickly by 100Hz but much like the Jomo Haka, the Comet keeps performing down to around 30-40Hz before it starts to attenuate and drop off.

      The bass elevation is around 50-150Hz for me so mid-bass warmth has a bit more presence than pure sub-bass power but the fact it can show some punch down there at all is to be commended. Also, it has that balanced armature speed and snappiness with a slightly shorter level of decay than a typical dynamic driver.

      Whilst it may not have a huge level of texture and detail compared to dynamic drivers the Comets low-end is quick paced and punchy with decent depth. I can’t see this letting anyone down on EDM and synth wave genres."

      • Thanks for the detailed reply!

    • +1

      Try TRN V80, I like them.

  • -4

    lol not even wireless

    • I was looking at wireless first but for decent audio quality, the money goes upward $200 pretty quickly.

      The issue is the actual performance of wireless which is reported to be inconsistent across almost all models (Jabra seems to do well but their sound quality is only okay) . i. e. it works with audio but not with video properly.

      Problems are okay if they are easy to resolve but the thing is…having to troubleshoot headphones is a deal breaker for me if it doesn't go away. Like anyone who had a bsod on Windows, it doesn't matter how pretty Win10 make the fault screen, it is still a bsod :)

      Maybe in a few years time, wireless will be properly implemented. Wouldn't be an issue if it was cheap but if you pay more than standard headphones that come with phones for free, you'd expect them to performance as like or better.

  • I can see the OP is very 'passionate' about their audio….

    • +1

      OP is passionate about a lot of things. This thing happened to be on sale.

  • As an old hand at lurking head-fi I was a bit iffy till I saw that comet is a sub-brand of ALO audio, go nuts guys there's will hold up. Maybe I'll finally replace my triple-fi's

    • This is my first ALO product, I take from your comment they have a good rep?

      • Yeah they've been around for atleast >10 years. They're known for making pretty high end headphone amps like the national and Rx, all pretty neutral, well regarded pieces of kit, if a bit expensive. By the sounds of things, if you haven't got them already, these are going to sound pretty different to your monster turbines (I had a pair too way back when). BA is usually more detailed with slightly less warmth.

        • Cool! I’m looking forward to it this week. Cheers mate.

          From what you said, it sounds modular. Does that mean I can just get a BLUETOOTH MMCX EARPHONE CABLE and make the comet IEMs partially or truely wireless?

          • @Hardearnedcash: No problem!

            From what I said?? But yeah you can, it is a bit headphone dependant, impedance and efficiency are going to affect your experience. I haven't looked into it, I know Fiio have the RC-BT, should work with these. I had a fiio e4 I think, was decent, and then an e17 Alpen, also pretty good for the price, I would expect the RC-BT to be decent quality.`

  • I think the most balanced, durable and imo best starting IEMs is the Shure SE 215s.

    My blue LE ones are still working til this day and its been 7 years - I have gone through 5 sets of cables though most of the cheap ones on ebay.

    I have just purchased a KZ ZSN though as everyone has been talking about them - and for the design, price and sound quality they are definitely worth it.

    I have also a Sol Republic Originals that have been working for 6 years that I use at work.

    My advice for any person looking into getting good headphones/earphones is to make sure you get detachable cables. Then they will last a very long time.

  • What a great looking whistle, might pick it up.

Login or Join to leave a comment