A few of the comments on the Laphroaig deal suggested checking out the Ardbeg 10yr, so did some searching and found it for $76.99 from Vintage Cellars. There is one down the road from the office, so going to check if it's also available in-store.
Seems to be $5 cheaper than Dan's and 1st Choice and $13 cheaper than Liquorland.
Although, there is a deal from 1st Choice with 2 tumblers for $82, if that takes your fancy.
Much smoother than Laphroaig, still keeps the strong peaty flavour but without being so overpowering.