In Reality, What Good Is a Home Security Camera Setup?

With the Amazon Prime Day sale, I looked up Ring cameras and saw that they are on sale. So, I am considering getting one but then I wonder what benefit they actually have. If my house is broken into, does the insurance company not pay out if I don't have insurance cameras? Surely, they still would. If the thieves wear a simple mask around their face, it can't be used to identify them in court, and if they don't, I'd have to have it at face level to capture their face and not the top of their heads.

So, what benefit does it actually bring or is it just for piece peace of mind?

-Update-
Looks like cameras aren't that useful.

-EDIT-
English bad, midnight shifts and tired.

Comments

  • +9

    In reality, whats a good home security camera setup?

    Reolink PoE

    • +1

      Also reolink wifi. Very satisfied with our 4x cameras and its person detection

      • +1

        THIS ! I have 4K 822A i guess with a hub that stores data. Great cameras with good price point as well.

      • Which model did ilu get reolink?

        Link please if u dont mind thanks

        • Reolink NVR RLN36 (this was probably overkill..)
          Reolink Duo2 WIFI (these can see 180 degrees)
          Reolink TrackMix
          Reolink E1 Zoom (indoor. Ultimately we turned off the zoom part cos of its location in the house)

          • @Geoffreys: Thanks. Oh u have a 36 camera setup

    • Can someone explain to me is there different "types" of PoE?

      When I last built I used Ubiquiti PoE cameras and bought a PoE switch for them to plug into, but still ended up having to use like a 240v "adapter" type thing which is a bit of a pain to be honest. I would rather just true PoE without the adapters how can I tell if these cameras will work like that with my switch?

      Ubiquiti used to be pretty good years ago but feel like they've dropped the ball lately, im looking to switch them over to something else Reolink ones look ok.

      • There are different standards with different max power ratings.

        https://www.black-box.de/en-de/page/23894/Resources/Technica…

      • Yes there are at least 5 types of PoE. Four of them are auto-negotiating. Your switch simply has to support the highest level of device you connect to it.

        They are explained in detail on the PoE Wikipedia page.

        Ubiquiti has been shite for years. It's not a 'dropped the ball recently' thing. If anything, they are slightly less shite now than five years ago.

  • +32

    Most thieves/burglars are opportunistic. If they look at two houses with noone home they are less likely to break into the one with security cameras.
    They dont stop break-ins, just push them onto someone else.

    • +1

      Exactly this. Same can be said for locks. It stops the opportunistic and the honest. Most homes are very easy to break into if you really want to.

      • Most homes are very easy to break into if you really want to.

        Sounds like you are trying to say something… Like a confession.

        I think you need a lawyer.

    • +1

      Yeah…seldom wearing a mask as well, most just throw a hoodie on and some even look up at the cameras and… Just assume they're fake? As they just proceed with their break-in.

    • -3

      Not necessarily

      They dont really care.
      In fact they will stand in front of the camera and wave to you because they know you cant get them.

      These days any house will do.

      The more the merrier.

      The only things that might stop them is more difficulty getting in an out.
      They certainly look for "easy targets"

    • +2

      An experienced thief will just shut the house power from the power cabinet - that would disable most people's security camera systems, or remove the security camera recorder on the way out.

      Agree many offenders don't care as they are minor or had so many priors they just don't need to care any more.

      • +5

        With smart meters, theres no reason not to have a lock on your meter box these days. Our PoE camera system is on battery backup as well.

        • How did you set up the battery backup? It's on my to-do list. Those PoE cameras are very power hungry.

        • +1

          Locking is a great idea, however make sure it’s a lock that your provider has a master key for so linesman and other contractors can get access in an emergency. An example from Energex for SEQ

          https://www.energex.com.au/our-services/metering/meter-locks

    • +1

      Having a second car on the driveway, dummy cameras and leaving dime lamp on in the living room that’s facing the front window all night will make them think someone is home. Dog signs on backyard gate and a lady that stay home is also the best deterrence.

      For those who doesn’t want cameras (like me).

  • +13

    I like the idea of home security cameras because if someone does break in, you'll have video evidence of all the things they stole.

    Never been in this position, but I think this would make an insurance claim easier - evidence that both you owned the item you're claiming and that it was lost during the burglary.

    • +2

      you'll have video evidence of all the things they stole.

      what about things they put in their pockets?

      • +2

        infrared cameras

      • +8

        including the ring doorbell camera on the way out!

    • +1

      If the burglar is carrying a big sack with a $ sign on it you're not likely to tell what got stolen with only external cameras, if you have internal cameras I hope they're not connected to the internet (or are on their own VLAN) because they don't get many security updates and can be easily exploited.

  • +18

    Looked at all the crimes happening in VIC. The crimes don't care about any of the cameras and will just break in anyway.

    For me, it is a piece of mind having a set of eyes whether I am home or not. Plus, it is better to have evidence than no evidence at all (especially for insurance and police reports etc). Also, the evidence can help join the dots if the individual has done multiple break-ins or thefts in terms of a time frame etc.

    Never had to make a theft claim, and hope I don't.

    • +8

      I've got notifications set up when my cameras detect people. So if I'm not home and I get a notification then I have a chance to call the cops straight away.

      Also lets me know about my nosy neighbours checking out by bins or not picking up after their dogs in my front yard.

    • -8

      No one with a working brain cell would choose to live in Victoriastan anyway

      • Victoria is just an example. It happens in QLD too.

  • +18

    does the insurance company not pay out if I don't have insurance

    yes… if you dont have insurance no one will pay you.

    • Midnight shifts… cheers

  • +5

    If your going to do it, invest in quality cameras that show clear pictures… not those blurry shit ones the news shows with 'have you seen this man'… and it could really be Big Foot.

    • +4

      Yes.

      Also, having provided camera footage to police from an old workplace that was broken into and then seeing that footage on the news, it looked nothing like the original quality - almost like someone had used a potato to screencap it. The original footage had the thief's faces clear and sharp. The news footage made them look like an uncooked cookie.

  • +5

    Benefits of a camera: (Example used based on a wired camera with NVR)
    1 - Piece of mind
    2 - 24 hour surveillance
    3 - Security (obviously)
    4 - Notifications of any events
    5 - Depending on camera (two way mic communications)
    6 - Nightvision (Colour at night)
    7 - Intimidating/Camera stands out
    8 - Evidence.
    9 - Late cameras have lighting (lights up your yard - dim)
    10 - Siren/Alarm on camera - Trigger
    11 - PTZ - Tracking (optional)
    12 - Viewing footage remotely

      • +23

        They can break into your house without consent but it's a 'Grey area' to record their audio talking to their bro's LOL. Yep… litigous society which makes lawyers richer

        • +3

          Exactly what I thought. Burglars do every single thing without our consent and yet we need their consent to record their audio. Lol. What kinda society do we live in!

      • +9

        The whole mic thing and recording audio without consent is a sticky pickle, even if they're a criminal it doesn't make it legal lol.

        If I am recording audio and video 24/7 on my own property, please tell me which law I am breaking here?
        If you find that piece of legislation, please do post here for everyone's benefits.

        If the cameras are pointed right at my neighbour's backyard, then that's a different matter altogether.

        • +8

          Yeah, people often misinterpret the privacy laws - there is no court in the country that is going to not admit evidence of a camera with audio because it "breaks" privacy laws, likewise, no burglar is going to be able to sue you for breaching their privacy.

        • +5

          Yeah, people often misinterpret the privacy laws - there is no court in the country that is going to not admit evidence of a camera with audio because it "breaks" privacy laws, likewise, no burglar is going to be able to sue you for breaching their privacy.

        • Recording audio of your neighbour when you are not party to the conversation can be illegal. Whether or not someone will do anything about it is a different question.

          • @lunchbox99:

            Recording audio of your neighbour when you are not party to the conversation can be illegal.

            You missed the part where the devices are located on my own property.

            Furthermore, once again I ask please show me the exact clause of the exact legislation that you think makes audio recording (on my own property) illegal but not video recording. It is almost laughable how many people just like to throw around the world "illegal" for audio recording on private property.

            Whether or not someone will do anything about it is a different question.

            Yes, what can they do?

            • +1

              @DoctorCalculon: It doesn’t matter where they are located. It is illegal in most of australia to record a conversation without consent when you are not a party of the conversation.

              I see you are in Melbourne. Here is an explanation of the law in Victoria and a link to the relevant legislation.
              https://recordinglaw.com/victoria-recording-laws/

              Section 6 Regulation of installation, use and maintenance of listening devices
              (1) Subject to subsection (2), a person must not knowingly install, use or maintain a listening device to overhear, record, monitor or listen to a private conversation to which the person is not a party, without the express or implied consent of each party to the conversation.
              Penalty:
              In the case of a natural person, level 7 imprisonment (2 years maximum) or a level 7 fine (240 penalty units maximum) or both;
              In the case of a body corporate, 1200 penalty units.

              What can they do - they can sue you to remove devices that are located in places where you can record their conversations without consent. Is it likely to happen? No unless you have bad blood with your neighbours, but it is certainly possible.

              So if you have audio recording between houses, outside windows etc then keep it to yourself. If your neighbours become aware of it, they could force you to relocate the device.

              • -1

                @lunchbox99:

                What can they do - they can sue you to remove devices that are located in places where you can record their conversations without consent.

                Certainly they can try in vain and waste their money.
                I control all the surveillance devices on my property — outdoors and indoors. As this is a civil matter, good luck building a case without a warrant.
                How will they know if I have a NVR sitting in my server rack? Or, I could just have some really good fake Dahua cameras from AliExpress.

                https://recordinglaw.com/victoria-recording-laws/

                These laws you point to are all in the civil jurisdiction unless someone is being a peeping tom, which is not the case here.

                Please don't go fearmongering. The surveillance is for the purposes of security. IDGAF about the feelings of my neighbours.
                If my place gets robbed, they are suddenly not going to come up with a description of the perpetrator.

                Also, most people don't go pointing cameras at their neighbour's backyard without their consent.

                So if you have audio recording between houses, outside windows etc then keep it to yourself

                My front facing PTZ cameras seem to advertise themselves well with sirens, flashing red & blue lights, and two-way talk.
                They track anyone on the footpaths and on the streets - all public areas.

                If your neighbours become aware of it, they could force you to relocate the device.

                Yes, only if I am stupid enough to install cameras specifically pointed into their backyard without their prior consent (or, if I don't show them I have masked their property). Otherwise, that is a clear invasion of their privacy.

                They certainly cannot force me to remove my front cameras which have a legitimate security purpose.

              • -1

                @lunchbox99:

                Section 6 Regulation of installation, use and maintenance of listening devices
                (1) Subject to subsection (2), a person must not knowingly install, use or maintain a listening device to overhear, record, monitor or listen to a private conversation to which the person is not a party, without the express or implied consent of each party to the conversation.
                Penalty:
                In the case of a natural person, level 7 imprisonment (2 years maximum) or a level 7 fine (240 penalty units maximum) or both;
                In the case of a body corporate, 1200 penalty units.

                The operative words are: private conversation.

                My lawyer would argue, if you are having a conversation right in front of my property on the footpath before you plan to rob my place, that area isn't exactly private, is it?

                Secondly, how will you prove my optical recording devices are also recording audio without a warrant to the premises?
                You cannot obtain a warrant because I haven't violated any criminal statutes, and/or there is no probable cause.

                • @DoctorCalculon: And your camera placement could allow you to illegally record private conversations. The example I specifically gave is where people place them between houses and they are adjacent to the neighbours windows.

                  Listen, you can argue till you’re blue in the face, You’re wrong.

                  • -1

                    @lunchbox99:

                    And your camera placement could allow you to illegally record private conversations.

                    So, what? You cannot legally enter my property to prove it within the context of a civil litigation.

                    Listen, you can argue till you’re blue in the face, You’re wrong.

                    Sure thing, bud. You still haven't addressed how you go about hypothesis to actual proof when no crime has been committed.

                    My cameras have been recording audio for many years. I am not suddenly going to take them down because someone might sue me.
                    In fact, I have to plans to install more security cameras as more advanced devices come into the market.

                    Furthermore, I have provided footage to Victoria Police in the past without scrubbing audio for a vandalism incident.

                    In a nutshell, are you saying folks shouldn't install security cameras with audio (even front facing - covering public areas), because they could incidentally record a private conversation from a window of a neighbour?

                    If that is not what you are saying, could you please suggest something a bit more practical.

                  • @lunchbox99:

                    Listen, you can argue till you’re blue in the face, You’re wrong.

                    Nope, it's you.

                    Hand back your Cornflakes packet law degree.

        • -1

          who said cameras were internal?
          I was going off external front porch cameras as the assumption, records more than just the crim.
          If it's during the act of a crime that's one thing, if they scope out the place a week before hand but don't break the law you are

      • +2

        even if they're a criminal it doesn't make it legal lol.

        Lol

  • So what benefit does it actually bring or is it just for piece of mind?

    The only benefit I see is you get to post the grainy night time footage on Facebook community groups saying…

    Can anyone identify these criminals

    FFS

    piece of mind?

    Also, classic ozbargain.

    • How about the intelligent crimimals' cars parked nearby the camera captures? Colour and make/model stands out like dogs genitals. Number plate depending on distance and camera.

      • -3

        I'd assume they'd use a stolen car, well, assuming they are intelligent enough.

        • +2

          Which ever way you look at it, if they want to break in, they'll break in. You can completely fortify your home, CCTV, alarms, high fences, upgraded locks, Doberman, external security home monitoring services etc. I have CCTV and can't live without it. Why? I sleep well at night as i get constant notifications of any movement remotely. That's what matters to me.

          • -1

            @vinni9284: I get that, first kid came along, and I was worrying about them constantly. Got myself a baby monitor with a screen next to my bed and I slept well again.

            -Edit-
            You got upset by that comment? Hope you're not that fragile.

            • +2

              @FabMan: Well, you've contradicted yourself by saying they are not useful. They are useful, but it seems you don't want to spend too much? Sleeping well at night is already a win.

              • -7

                @vinni9284: I listened to your feedback, I liked your point. The conversation is wasted on you though, go cry under a blanket.

                • +2

                  @FabMan: I think you need monitoring in a different way

                  • -4

                    @vinni9284: Conversation and listening to other opinions is what it is about, you have forgotten that though. Edited your post, coward.

                    • +1

                      @FabMan: I think you're missing the point and interpreting differently.

                      • @vinni9284: Maybe, but you told me I am contradicting myself and then every post of mine on here got downvoted, I have made an assumption it was you, and I can't understand why when I was trying to show that I understood your point of view when talking about my kid with the sleeping monitor.

                        • @FabMan: I didn't downvote you

                          • -2

                            @vinni9284: Sorry then, someone is doing it as I'm talking to you. I thought you had made a good point and I was agreeing with you and then I got spammed negged and you said I was contradicting myself. Assumption just made a fool of me.

                            -Edit-
                            Haha Someone is being a snowflake and going through my posts to downvote on multiple forums. Haha, I guess I angered someone here somehow. No clue how.

                            • +1

                              @FabMan: The reason i said contradiction is that on your edit, is that you said that they aren't useful.

                              If you look at the analogy, CCTV is an external baby monitor for your home.

                              I'm not trying to put you down

                              • -4

                                @vinni9284: Reading other people's posts here, no one seems to have much usefulness in reality for them other than peace of mind, which is what I asked in my original question: "So, what benefit does it actually bring or is it just for peace of mind?". Peace of mind is all and good, but unlike the baby situation, I am not staying awake with worry about break in's.

                                • +1

                                  @FabMan: IMO peace of mind for me is everything. People pay to have that. But it's up to you. Good luck with your decision

                                • +1

                                  @FabMan: Some of the things I've found them useful for:
                                  - the police requested a clip which helped them timestamp some thieves exchanging merch from a petrol station robbery;
                                  - I engage household workers so I can check the times they arrive and depart (but it's not that I distrust them);
                                  - I can respond to events while I'm away from home, like the time a ducted aircon system got unloaded into my carport when it was supposed to be delivered a few houses away;
                                  - I get notified when parcels arrive and I feel the cameras deter porch pirates;
                                  - the motion sensor(s) can be used to trigger home automations;
                                  - I'm a carer so an indoor camera is setup to do welfare checks;
                                  - I can identify the losers who don't pick up after their dogs;
                                  - they log useful information, much like dashcams & public CCTV.

                                • @FabMan: lol that was your starting opinion. Almost every comment has explained the benefits, but you're only reading what you want to read

                                  • -2

                                    @SlickMick: What practical advice came before that post I made? Feel free to check by time stamps as before that post it seemed like it was mostly theoretical and feel good, not actual practical usage. You do realise how time works, right?

                                    • -1

                                      @FabMan: So you retract your comment?

                                      I'm out of negs. I'll try to remember to come back tomorrow.

                                      • -2

                                        @SlickMick: Retract my comment? It was accurate at the time. Geez, some people like you are a bit thick.

                                        See you tomorrow, snowflake.

    • -1

      "Also, classic ozbargain."

      Midnight shifts lead me to tired brain, fixed.

    • Ha. It went on so long unchecked, I was wondering if there was some kind of weird spelling concensus I didn’t know about.

    • -2

      Snowflake?

  • +2

    Personally I would invest in quality security doors over cameras. As for a camera being a deterrent, I'd just put 1 or 2 dummy cameras in very visible locations in front of the house

    • +2

      Yep I agree but renters can't afford this luxury when landlords refuse, however they can install wireless cameras/doorbells which provides them some form of security, at least. My tenants were shocked when I said yes to their request for me getting a security door for the place. Apparently they had asked for one at their last 3 properties and each time it was denied.

    • Dummy cameras kinda suck tho, as soon as you're next to it you know it's not real.

  • +8

    So what benefit does it actually bring or is it just for piece of mind?

    Piece of mind, seeing who is at the door before you answer it, seeing what happened is also handy for those 24/7 cameras.

    Watching your neighbour do the dirty on her FIFO husband while he is away.

    You know, all the normal things.

    • +9

      Watching your neighbour do the dirty on her FIFO husband while he is away.

      What a thread that was.

    • +1

      LOVE the FIFO comment.

  • +3

    Get one that alerts you to someone snooping around outside your house. That way you can go out and greet them with your baseball bat. Make sure to delete the recordings afterwards.

  • Just because a burglar wears a mask and a black jumper, doesn't necessarily means it will cover all their identifying tattoos.
    I know a guy who got burgled twice in quick succession by the same guy. Second time there were cameras (on a UPS) that allowed the cops to identify the criminal from his tatts that weren't covered.

    • did the guy get his stolen stuff back? or it was never going to happen anyway?

      • +1

        I recall he did get some of his stuff back from the second burglary.
        The criminal was actually one of his neighbours.
        The rest of his gear was replaced under insurance.

  • +1

    I get peace of mind. But if you're timing is perfect you could speak to your intruders remotely and give them a piece of your mind. In my 'hood they're an arguably proven visual deterrent.

  • +2

    Someone told me that if you don't want anything stolen, you should paint everything in your house with fresh dog poo. Then put a big sign outside your house that says, "Everything in this house is coated in fresh dog poo". Apparently this strategy has a 100% success rate.

  • What would be expected cost to getting professionally wiring and installation done for 8 cameras if I provide the nvr in SE Melbourne.
    Asking for a friend :)

    • -1

      6k plus GST + covid tax 20%.

  • Excellent for telling off my dogs!

  • Think about it if you were theif/robber… why take that extra risk, when the house next door doesnt have cameras

    Its like cars in the old days, criminals when interviewed said the same thing, yeah its easy to dismantle, but why take that extra effort. Same with alarm systems, it might be a fake red led indicating an alarm…. whty take that risk

    • +5

      The house with cameras has better stuff. The one with no camera and an old Camry out front isn't worth the effort.

  • +1

    Pro - you'll get some amazing footage of unidentifiable people in black hoodies breaking in
    Con - money you spent on cameras could have been spent on better locks and security so they couldn't break it

    • -1

      This is what I suspect.

    • @Typical16-bitEnjoyer - It depends who you work for, I have resources available to me at work that could allow me to access and obtain general public camera footage beyond the private property footage from the premise where I live. Also having worked for a military surplus retailer I could probably identify from certain characteristics the type and brand of the mask/balaclava that was worn too, which would help in narrowing down where they were purchased from.

Login or Join to leave a comment