We found a local concreter on FB and they have been a great bunch to deal with. Large driveway extension pour went well, however almost immediately (after letting the sealant dry for a week) the top layer is peeling under tyre tracks.
Concreter has been back again to reseal it, but the top surface still crumbles. They've said to keep driving on it and they will come back again eventually to reseal it.
I've suggested that the swirls they've put into the concrete are too rough and the ridges too big and this might be causing the top layer to peel. This isn't their first concreting job either so I'm a bit puzzled as to why this is happenning?
Has anyone had any experience with this?
No concrete surface treatment is immune, the only way that you would've been able to avoid this is to use a black pigment concrete aggregate or fine grained asphalt.
Painted coatings will always degrade, on our commercial jobs we're lucky to get 4-5 years. We used this stuff pretty much the best in the industry but its not cheap and still is only considered temporary on areas trafficable by vehicles.
Generally brushed finishes will chip to a degree so you are partially right, however this is a side effect of painting concrete. Might just be better off repainting constantly until it no longer chips? Is the surface tacky or is the sealant like a teflon finish.