Is Amazon's Subscribe and Save System a Scam?

Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:28

Ok, I know what the Ozbargain mob mentality is like so I expect every idiot and his dog will come out calling me a moron, but hear me out.
As you all know, deals are regularly posted here for Amazon products.
Many of them are pantry staple types that have a subscribe and save option.
This option solicits entering into an ongoing arrangement with Amazon by:

  1. being the default purchase option on many of these types of staple product, and
  2. offering a 10% discount.
    The subscribe and save box tells you that you get a discount, that you can choose the number of items, and the delivery frequency - but it does not tell you that the price you are agreeing to buy the product at is not the price Amazon might charge you next delivery.

It is not until you click the 'learn more' button that this information is revealed.
I strongly suspect that Amazon relies on people not clicking this button and not knowing that they can change the price at whim for the next delivery - because
WHO IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WOULD AGREE TO BUY STUFF ON AN ONGOING BASIS WITHOUT KNOWING WHAT THEY WERE GOING TO BE CHARGED!?!

So, Ozbargain community, is this dodgy behaviour on Amazon's part?
Is their dodginess countered by our dodginess is signing up for the initial discount and then immediately cancelling our S&S after we scored the extra 10%?

Poll Options

  • 23
    1. The Subscribe and Save option is dodgy by Amazon
  • 23
    2. The Subscribe and Save then cancel after getting the initial 10% option is dodgy by Ozbargainers
  • 146
    3. Neither is dodgy
  • 7
    4. Both are dodgy
  • 8
    5. Bikies.
General Discussion

Related Stores

Amazon AU
Amazon AU
Marketplace

Comments

  • Jimothy Wongingtons on 18/01/2022 - 17:30
    +4

    If they stooged you with a price hike you could just do free returns?

    Also what kind of self respecting ozbargainer doesnt instantly cancel the subscription/ read the terms and conditions before signing up?

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:32
      +1

      Well, I do, but not everyone is a professional like your friendly neighbourhood Ozbargainer.

      • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:49

        I will add Jimothy that I did feel a little guilty cancelling my subscription after my Coco Pops arrived, having taken the 10% benefit.

        • Jimothy Wongingtons on 18/01/2022 - 18:41
          +5

          1 less ivory butt-scratcher for Bezos

        • toomuchdogfur on 18/01/2022 - 19:28

          They're still making money, don't sweat it. The other 90% of people who didn't cancel their subs are paying for your 10% off. Also see:

          • Credit card late fees and interest
          • Crazy big new credit card sign up bonuses (AMEX Explorer and ANZ Black for example)
          • "First month free" subscriptions
          • New subscriber discounts
    • HairyChickens on 18/01/2022 - 18:51
      +1

      Are you able to buy a subscribe and save item once and then cancel immediately every time to get that 10%?

      • Jimothy Wongingtons on 18/01/2022 - 18:58
        +1

        Yes happens all the time

      • zonra on 18/01/2022 - 19:32
        +4

        Yep, I’ve done exactly this each and every time.
        S&S to get the initial 10% off, set it at 6 month recurrence.
        Then just go into my subscriptions once in a while to cancel all S&S.
        Haven’t been caught out so far (touches wood).

        It’s like having credit cards, the benefits shouldn’t cost you anything as long as you know what you’re doing.

        • Jimothy Wongingtons on 18/01/2022 - 19:43

          They do make you jump through quite a few pages to cancel, I regularly have 20-30 subs to cancel and is a bit annoying.

        • spaiydz on 18/01/2022 - 22:29

          Also, if you buy something on S&S that is sent to a different address (as a gift or for a friend), it is shown in a separate S&S section.

          ie. it is not aggregated in the same list together.

  • netjock on 18/01/2022 - 17:37

    but it does not tell you that the price you are agreeing to buy the product at is not the price Amazon might charge you next delivery

    Guess you didn't read the comments on all the other threads.

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:41

      As you would have identified had you read my post, I am aware of this, however, most Amazon buyers are not sophisticated, worldly, knowledgeable Ozbargainers - and it is no answer to the claim that Amazon is far from transparent in their selling practices to say that buyers could have found this out by trawling the Ozbargain forums…

  • Morien on 18/01/2022 - 17:42
    +1

    Like you've said, when you click "learn more", it says the following:
    "Save on auto-deliveries
    Choose from thousands of eligible Subscribe and Save products. Note that prices may increase or decrease from delivery to delivery."

    That isn't at all hidden. It's the first thing (of 3 short sentences) that you see when clicking "learn more". Maybe it could be made more clear. But I think it's already pretty clear.

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:44

      Understood, but I would say that if they wanted to make it clear they could easily put it in the initial subscribe and save box so you don't have to click through to see it.

      • pharkurnell on 18/01/2022 - 18:53
        +3

        Maybe a personal phone call to each person globally that signs up explaining the situation?

  • koplik8 on 18/01/2022 - 17:43

    I just worked this out that the prices fluctuate on some products. I've got a few items on S&S. Picked up some ongoing great bargains. Learnt my lesson and regularly check the page and the new prices for the next round of deliveries.

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:45
      +1

      Be careful - the mob here will tell you that you aren't Ozbargain worthy because you didn't inherit this knowledge feeding from your mother's teat.

      • koplik8 on 18/01/2022 - 17:59
        +1

        Haha yeah yeah!
        Well I was getting Omo sensative 2L for $9.50- supermarket is $22. The cheapest you can get it is 50% off at $11. Amazon is still cheaper.

        Huggies Dry Nites are $8.50 a pack on Amazon. WW Darwin was $15 and CWH is $12.50. Even on special I haven't seen them lower than Amazon's price.

        You've got to shop smart and know your prices

    • hamwhisperer on 19/11/2022 - 10:41

      Hey you wouldn't happen to have a list of other good things to add to subscribe and save would you? I'm happy to monitor the prices but I want to automate more of my shopping.

  • test123123 on 18/01/2022 - 17:46
    +2

    I like it. It’s convenient.

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 17:48

      Would it still be convenient if the price doubled between deliveries?
      I would actually love the system - if they locked in the price you agreed to pay when you signed up.

      • Hybroid on 18/01/2022 - 18:41
        +8

        That isn't practical as prices do fluctuate, both up and down. That's why you're given a pre-dispatch e-mail to confirm the products and prices in next S&S order. You can review and cancel if you wish. What's dodgy about that?

        Forgot or weren't able to review in time? Simply return products free for full refund. What's dodgy about that?

        S&S being the default option is because it's the cheapest offered. If it was the other way around, you'd probably be calling them "dodgy" for listing the higher price option as default instead of the 10% off one……

  • apsilon on 18/01/2022 - 17:49
    +10

    You get an email before each shipment asking you to review the upcoming delivery. You can see the price at that time and make changes if you want. I don't see any other way to do it.

    • apiecost on 19/01/2022 - 00:08
      +1

      This. Just check the email to see if you want the item at the price and schedule. I often push some items back another month. e.g. drinks for work, if we already have enough of something I adjust the timing.

  • Neoika on 18/01/2022 - 17:54

    Yes to some extent, no to some extent.

  • Daabido on 18/01/2022 - 18:07

    You can't save stupid people from themselves. Some will get burned; some will learn, some will not.

  • dahax77 on 18/01/2022 - 18:18
    +1

    Not dodgy at all. Of course prices of products fluctuate over time. Sign up, get the discount and cancel. Repeat as needed whenever I want the same product - easy win-win for me.

    • pharkurnell on 18/01/2022 - 18:52

      Of course prices of products fluctuate over time

      Exactly.. they do in bricks and mortar as well… why should online be different?

  • raptormesh on 18/01/2022 - 18:23

    They send you emails regarding future deliveries with the prices. If you don't like them you can just cancel, like I did in many occasions.

    Maybe learn what is a scam?

  • AustriaBargain on 18/01/2022 - 18:47

    I think it's just an incentive to get people to use subscribe option. Even if the prices were locked in having customers rely on subscribing would be worth it. The price changes are probably out of Amazon's control. I wish there were an option to get even bigger discounts if you committed to subscribing to an item over a period of a year or so, instead of being able to cancel whenever you want. If Amazon could provide me my noodle soup at cheaper than Woolworths then I'd commit to a year's worth.

  • holdenmg on 18/01/2022 - 18:50

    I think you are trying to conflate 7/11 Fuel Price Lock App features with Amazon items for sale.

    Amazon can't really be locked in forever allowing for that you are already getting an up-front discount by subscribing.

    It is true that Amazon may derive some volume purchasing discount or be able to forward buy against "locked-in" orders.

    Wouldn't you rather have the upfront saving and forward option (but not the obligation)?

    If not, then don't subscribe.

  • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 19:07

    How about if I phrase the question this way:

    "Do you think the average punter [not the professionals on Ozbargain] signing up to S&S might think that they will continue to get the same price for future deliveries?"

    This is really the heart of the issue for me. If I put it this way, does it make anyone else think that maybe it could be more clear by Amazon?

    • holdenmg on 18/01/2022 - 19:11

      They might.

      But do Amazon represent that they might still enjoy the same price (and if so for how long).
      (or it is some people might assume).

      And if you subscribe, do you enjoy the lower price if the price falls?

  • bmxr on 18/01/2022 - 19:15
    +1

    The products we subscribe to already match the 50% off specials at Colesworth, and then beat it by 10% and then deliver it for free!

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 19:17

      Well, for $60 pa.

      • kiitos on 19/01/2022 - 07:55

        No, I don't think you need Prime. My subscription is delivered with free delivery whereas I needed to pay delivery when I needed an extra one outside the subscription schedule

  • zonra on 18/01/2022 - 19:34
    +3

    Average consumers these days: ‘Oh no, I didn’t read the terms properly. What a scam!’

    • Almost Banned on 18/01/2022 - 19:48

      To be fair - when was the last time you read an entire EULA, or even the FB terms of service?

      • SF3 on 18/01/2022 - 21:24
        +1

        That’s Appeal to Ignorance.

      • Morien on 18/01/2022 - 22:53

        Not a valid comparison. This isn't a multiple page document. It's the first sentence (of 3) when you click 'Read more'.

  • lilith on 18/01/2022 - 22:16
    +4

    I actually wish there was a function to only send my subscriptions if below a certain price. I’d leave more active that way instead of constantly cancelling them.

  • toomuchcoffee on 18/01/2022 - 23:20
    +1

    I think even if a person automatically cancels their S&Ss Amazon win by getting the person to engage with their ap/website.

    I usually don't cancel straight away, but review them at a later date (99% I cancel - even if the price hasn't changed I can't seem to commit to any schedule!). There's a good chance I'll browse around and therefore a chance I'll buy something else.

  • dmbminaret on 19/01/2022 - 10:31

    it does not tell you that the price you are agreeing to buy the product at is not the price Amazon might charge you next delivery.

    Some non ozbargainers don't care about price. They want convenience and even tell Alexa to order dishwasher tablets regardless of the price.

  • bamzero on 19/01/2022 - 13:33

    I've never let a S&S ride until the next delivery, but don't they email you before the next delivery with the price?

  • OzHunterNSW on 19/01/2022 - 14:35
    -1

    They usually sell postage free… there is no need for you to subscribe to yet another subscription… you don't need Spoterfy… you don't need 50 subscriptions floating around in your name… make your life simple…. don't do it

  • Savas on 19/01/2022 - 22:13
    +2

    I think it is sneaky .. I have no problems canceling it immediately but I feel bad for the people who get ripped off since normally subscriptions lock in the price. For example, it’s not like Spotify charges people a random price each month.

  • shaybisc on 20/01/2022 - 08:38

    Set and forget customer is obviously ideal for any business but it must suit a lot of sheeple too.

    • Almost Banned on 20/01/2022 - 14:46

      I definitely think they rely on the lazy/dumb tax.

  • paulojr on 11/11/2023 - 22:26

    I was curious so I gave it a try!

    Ordered some general soap for $9 and set it to re-order at a specific time-frame ensuring the next delivery would be after we came back from holidays.

    Whilst on holidays we saw a failed attempt to debt the visa card and tracked it back to the subscription where they went to delivery goods when we were away not following the subscription schedule we set. (I took screen prints to confirm what we set)

    I use a specific visa for online and usually blocked it whilst traveling otherwise I am sure the order would have gone through and been delivered whilst we were away.

    We had experience recently with Amazon keeping a copy of the card CVV in breach of PCI so now have low trust with Amazon AU.

    I went to check what had happened I wasn't any way I could find to actually see what was being charged but it wasn't $9 but was clear the schedule had been changed to a monthly frequency without our input (bugs???). I think it was now $13.50 based on the product link.

    So in practical terms given it went to debt the card without even an email notification or anything telling us what it was going to charge just an email stating "we were unable to ship your subscribe and save auto delivery", I vote for it to be in the "scam" bucket. Its bad enough that its so difficult to manage the subscriptions not have a notification before stating the price I think really is not acceptable.

    Another thought:
    What I have noticed with Amazon Australia is you've got to be really careful to stick to just deals. e.g. I've seen stuff that is well priced (thanks to our good friends here on Ozbargain who report the deals) but if you go back to the same seller after the deal has expired often the Amazon prices are massively ramped up!, so the idea of subscribing for repeated purchases using Amazon Australia doesn't seem work on a platform that does not care amount maintaining everyday low prices. I guess this does align to the lazy tax thinking.. if you're lazy enough not to be checking your prices then you pay the premium! But then in that case, might as well just grab it from coles or woollies and support local.

    Also we've found that cancelling amazon for filled orders is near impossible, we've tried a few times and always the goods come anyway and you have to then ship it back, plus if the item is lost or not delivered there is no option to report it, you have to call or go onto chat. We spent 5 hours on calls and chat last time dealing with what appeared to be robotic humans just to try and explained to them something was not delivered, even after 5 hours our account still shows the delivery and charge hasn't been fixed so I think the idea of simply returning it if it arrived by accident is probably not worth any benefits that the subscription feature might provide.

    As such.. I voted this as a scam feature.

Login or Join to leave a comment
Login Join