Do I really need UHS-I (100 MB/s) to play 1080p video on an Android TV box?

I have an X99 box with 32GB flash storage. It has a microSD slot, so I'm looking to expand, and won't have to be keep deleting watched movies to get new ones (the box is away from the phone line, so streaming is not an option over wireless — and powerline extension didn't work out much better either).

Question is: is that a good reason to buy Samsung's 128GB UHS-I microSDXC @ $30 (+ s/h), or will class 10 (i.e. 10 MB/s suffice)? Further, will this box actually be able to transfer data at those speeds, or are there other internal bottlenecks? Cheers.

Related Stores

eBay Australia
eBay Australia
Marketplace

Comments

  • +1

    Most devices should have UHS data bus meaning that to realize the full potential of your device you should be using a SD card that is rated UHS.

    According to Sandisk, a class 10 SDHC card has a minimum of 10MB/s transfer rate.

    UHS Class 1 also starts off with a minimum of 10MB/s transfer rate, so whether you use a UHS-1 or Class10 SDHC card, both should a similar minimum speed rating.

    I've been using non UHS cards in mobile phones and cameras (min class 10 however) and recording fine at 1080p. Remember that the write speeds of flash memory is generally a lot slower than read speeds, so it's likely that a C10 card can actually read perhaps two or three times faster than it can write.

  • +1

    Afaik, any 32GB MicroSD card will be able to play back at Full HD bitrates (8 - 12 Mbps(bits) which is around 1 - 1.5 MB/s). To put it into perspective, a Class 10 SD Card can record Full HD video.

    Don't know about other potential bottlenecks of your system, but I'd get the faster one anyway just because I wouldn't want to wait that long for stuff to transfer.

  • If you have some spare USB ports a thumbdrive will do. Just get one of the higher speed ones and you should be fine. Netflix 4k plays at around 15mbps, high quality 1080p bluray rips might get closer to 100mbps. but they're probably around 40-60mbps.

    • It does, but any reason why a thumbdrive rather than microSD? Cheaper?

      • Well not really. probably about the same price. I was thinking it would be more convenient to use a usb stick than fiddling around with a microsd if you have to remove it to load movies.

        • Not really; I'll just use it as an "external" drive. I'm doing the same on my MacBook Air. In fact, it's less "fiddly" that having a thumb drive pronging out like a… sore thumb. Literally.

        • +1

          @wisdomtooth: yeah fair enough 128gb should do nicely.

Login or Join to leave a comment