XBox One Elite controller. The spiel: "Give your gaming a helpful boost with the Xbox Elite Wireless Controller. It adapts to your hand size and play style, so you get better control across all gaming genres. The new, faceted D-pad enables easier and more reliable combo execution, while the traditional D-pad provides precise control to change weapons or call in a strike."
Tried this at PAX (and just bought one), feels solid and well made - very adjustable with widely good reviews.
Edit: This appears to be an official Microsoft Store on eBay, but user Shads has contacted MS who say they don't have an official eBay store. I'll leave this up for now but I'd probably be ensuring to purchase through PayPal (as I did), just in case the buyer protection thing becomes necessary :/
Not the cheapest it has ever been. But a decent price from the manufacturer directly (though see above). 1.35% cashback from CashRewards will work for this too. http://cashrewards.com.au/ebay-australia/
Old one? New one will come with bluetooth eventually, like the newer controller S models.